Vinyl LP pressing includes bonus CD edition. 2012 album from the Christian Alt-Rock band featuring original vocalist Chris Carrabba (Dashboard Confessional). Further Seems Forever released its much-lauded debut album The Moon Is Down in 2001, and singer Chris Carrabba exited the group to pursue his solo career with Dashboard Confessional. But, no one likes a story that ends so abruptly. So when FSF's original lineup reunited in 2005, hope for something more glimmered. Penny Black both mirrors and expands upon Further Seems Forever's early aesthetic.. From front to back, Penny Black is the record both fans and critics have been longing for.